Welcome!

The background art you see is part of a stained glass depiction by Marc Chagall of The Creation. An unknowable reality (Reality 1) was filtered through the beliefs and sensibilities of Chagall (Reality 2) to become the art we appropriate into our own life(third hand reality). A subtext of this blog (one of several) will be that we each make our own reality by how we appropriate and use the opinions, "fact" and influences of others in our own lives. Here we can claim only our truths, not anyone else's. Otherwise, enjoy, be civil and be opinionated! You can comment by clicking on the blue "comments" button that follows the post, or recommend the blog by clicking the +1 button.

Tuesday, March 18, 2014

Fondness for Battle

Standing on the bluffs above Fredericksburg, watching futile Union charges uphill into his thundering cannons, Robert E. Lee observed, “It is well that war is so terrible; else we should grow too fond of it.”  I’m afraid we have, nowadays in the pitched battles waged daily between our political parties.  Neither blood nor ink is spilled any longer in these unceasing wars – it’s so much easier to pour out the mutual hatreds and slanders via the internet – but the consequences remain terrible.  Families go without food stamps they need for feeding their children, drinking water is polluted, health care is lacking, diseased poultry is uninspected, businesses are bankrupted, future disasters are precipitated by current inactions.  The parties each charge the other with actions designed not for the benefit of the country but to promote the party’s own fortunes.  And both parties are right about that.
The problem is that large amounts of money must be raised in our current campaigning by advertising mode of electioneering.  The days are long gone when campaigning was done by shaking hands and kissing babies and issuing occasional quotes.  Now, due to the length of the election cycle, the numbers of people to be reached, and the Citizens United decision, endless cash is required, and it is easier to raise money by instilling hatred of an enemy than by seeking a common goal with those who differ.  Party professionals know that, and hatred is their daily product.  I get at least half a dozen political fundraising emails every day, and none of them is even close to the “love your enemy” message I get in church on Sunday – even when the political email arrives on Sunday morning.  They have grown too fond of their warfare.
George Washington’s farewell address included his famous warning against letting the strife of “party factions” undermine the Republic that he and the other Founding Fathers had devoted themselves to building.  Washington went on to say “The common and continual mischiefs of the spirit of party are sufficient to make it the interest and duty of a wise people to discourage and restrain it. It serves always to distract the public councils and enfeeble the public administration.”  More recently, John Dingell, announcing his retirement from Congress after 58 years, proved Washington right by saying he did so because Congress had become “obnoxious” in its partisanship.  Dingell pointed out that the current Congress had set a record by passing only 57 pieces of legislation and blamed a common “disregard of our country, our Congress, and our governmental system.”   That 57 pieces of legislation going to the White House was less than the number of times the House passed a repeal of the Affordable Care Act knowing in advance it would go nowhere in the Senate.
G.B, Shaw wittily observed that a nation is created by people divided by a common language and united by a common enemy, but when the common language is mutual hatred, the nation can also be destroyed.  We live in dangerous days.  Everything from class warfare to climate change to global terrorism to unending economic stagnation threatens us.  In some possible outcomes, our survival as a democracy is indeed threatened.  Those dangers can be both a threat and an opportunity to us.  One more quote – Aristotle was the first to get into the act of combining “common” and “enemy” into one sentence by writing “Even the bitterest of enemies can be united by a common danger.”  Our fondness for battle has got us into the wrong wars against ourselves.  We need to raise our sights to see the dangers we share and to relearn how to work together on them.  Politicians need to remember, like Dingell, why they set out into politics in the first place.  If it was purely from hate, they are in the wrong business.

By itself, of course, just hating each other less is not enough.  We need to try out things that have worked elsewhere, like the British practice of severely limiting the election cycle, or requiring media to provide free or low cost political ads as a requirement for licensing.  And Citizens United, and the underlying definition of corporations as political people, needs serious rethought. When you need lots of money to campaign, the temptations of lobbyists and PACs are too great.  And “here there be tygers.”  The need for money to get elected has itself become one of our greatest dangers.  Defeating it should unite us.

Friday, March 7, 2014

The Voices of America

One of the interesting aspects of the current wide-ranging discussions about Ukraine is that there seems an American consensus about the topic and a shouting match in the discussion of it.  The consensus is that Putin has gravely violated the sovereignty of Ukraine, that he must suffer serious consequences for doing so, and that while military confrontation must be avoided, economic and political sanctions of all kinds are appropriate.  But you couldn't tell that from the shouting.  President Obama is talking about the costs Putin must bear, while apoplectic senators like McCain are screaming from the podium and senior statesmen like Kissinger and Albright are urging calm. Talk show hosts are, as usual, frothing.
Years ago I sang in an excellent A Capella chorus whose director kept impressing on us that one of the most difficult things in choral music is to sing in unison, “with one voice.”  We were very good at that, but it took hours of practice.  In American politics it’s much harder and may never be achieved.  It’s part of the American culture.  The first CEO of General Motors was known to break up a meeting in frustration because everyone agreed on an important topic.  He treated consensus as a sign that not enough thought had been given to the subject.  It’s part of our history: Massachusetts even threatened to secede over the War of 1812.
What makes it unduly hard these days is the perceived need of politicians of both parties for consistent disagreement with others. It reminds me of the teenager stage when constant disagreement with parents is an imperative.  But they grow out of that.  Emerson noted that ”a foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds”, and I suppose the minds of some politicians are as little as any.  Politicians in our history had no such need.  Henry Clay was a notable hawk during the 1812 War but strongly opposed the Mexican War, as did Abraham Lincoln, who later led us into the Civil War.  And their eloquence did not require shouting.
This of course is just wishing on my part.  As noted, cacophony is part of the American makeup.  Speaking nonsense is one way we exercise our freedom of speech, and we could not endure it if it were gone.  But sometimes it is important that others not part of our culture understand what we are saying, and that is a responsibility that should be understood and accepted by all public voices.  What turned the opposing voices of our past into an American harmony was realistic principle which agreed or disagreed as necessary, without regard to positions taken by the other political party.  It’s been said that part of the current crisis is that Putin does not really understand America, and our political voices are not helping.

It used to be that in an international crisis, domestic political voices quieted down and left the talking to the President.  Talking stopped at the shore line.  It’s not that way anymore, but I can wish that some of our political voices old enough to remember that era would think to bring it back.

Wednesday, February 26, 2014

Irrational Knowledge

Little side moments in life sometimes tell you more about yourself than a deep analysis.  I remember practicing just from curiosity with pastels, when suddenly the total mess of colors on the page came together to somewhat resemble the picture I’d set out to draw.  Wow!  Or that time I got to emote in the class play. Or that time I really had fun, broken glasses and all, in a college game of hand ball.  Political speech writer and columnist Michael Gerson, writing in the Washington Post the other day, told about the moments he enjoys reading about cosmology even without a clue about what the equations are saying.  That’s all useless knowledge, the kind you can’t earn a dime from and that economists contrast with rational ignorance.  But it surely is fun, and a vital part of what makes us human.
Actually, it turns out that it can be quite useful, only in ways you’d never expect.  Argentina has discovered that making music a required course in school has resulted in significant reductions in juvenile trouble-making, and has improved the general education skills of their children.  A nephew of mine turned a youthful interest in art into a career in helping troubled youth via art therapy.  The son of friends of ours took occasional breaks from his work as an electrical engineer to enjoy theater, until he discovered that his real love was backstage engineering work in theaters, and made a career of it.
That’s why it troubles me that so many public school systems are managing penny-pinching budgets and the costs of increased security by eliminating courses like art, music and theater.  Instead of using art and music to soothe the savage breasts of teenagers, they are hiring more guards.  That they are also limiting the life chances and pleasures of living for their future adults is of no account.  How many future architects and artists and singers are being lost?  Who knows?  But from a utilitarian viewpoint, those are jobs, too.
The problem mostly doesn’t exist in private schools.  They know the value of those “soft” courses, and make them an integral part of their education.  I’m grateful that the private school where my grandsons attend makes music a standard requirement, right along with the fine math, science, history and literature courses they provide.  They know the value of such courses and are willing to pay for them.
The problem is that necessary penny pinching  of public schools.  School boards and county commissions are often stocked with hard-nosed business men who never had a music class and see no need for others to have one either – not at the taxpayers’ expense.  And career educators, who should know better, try to please their bosses.  That was the message of that really good movie, Mr. Holland’s Opus.  That a shy teenage girl had been turned into a future state governor by the experience of studying music was meaningless; Mr. Holland’s job as music teacher was still eliminated.
Yes, better readin’, writin’ and ‘rithmatic need desperately to be taught and cost money to do so.  But so do music and drama and art.  And they too must be paid for.  And as is obvious from the private – public school contrast, it’s the poorer kids who suffer when they’re not.  The well known reason is that the costs of public education are funded by the property tax.  Poor neighborhoods lack the high property values that enable good education.

There’s a lot of talk these days about education reform, from charter and magnet schools to core standards.  There’s value in all those things.  But no real reform is going to occur until public schools are better funded, and that requires reforming the property tax system.  Economists and other pennypinchers go on about the rationality of ignorance, but that doesn't work anymore in our 21st century world.  It’s time we started celebrating the irrational human beauty of knowledge for knowledge’s sake, and started digging into our pockets to provide it.  Our children, and our futures, deserve it.

Friday, February 21, 2014

The Theology of Climate Change Denial

When Galileo obtained one of the first telescopes from its Dutch inventor, he set busily at work examining things like the surface of the moon and discovering the moons of Jupiter.  The response from the Inquisition was fascinating.  The telescope, they declared, was a creation of the Devil designed to lure faithless souls to damnation by presenting them with false images of worlds not in accord with scripture.  If science contradicts belief then science, not belief, must be in error.  That of course is the mark of the “close your eyes and believe harder” branch of theology that we thought abandoned soon thereafter.  Not so.  Only one hundred years after the Scopes trial, the hard facts of science are once again being challenged, this time by the theologians of the “Don’t blame my SUV” community.
Twice this week, I have been astounded by the theological bent that climate change denial has taken.  By the way, personal note, I am a person both of faith and of science; I find no conflict between them.  The first experience this week was after I gave a short lead-in about the recent IPCC report before a group discussion on the impact of climate change on world food supplies.  A participant announced firmly that he could not accept climate change because 1) a friend back in 1980 had predicted a six inch rise in sea level by 2000 and been wrong, and 2) Eisenhower had warned against grant-seeking scientists at the same time he warned against the military-industrial complex.  I tried to encourage the “regret-free” approach recommended by the IPCC, and hope I at least left him thinking, but I’m doubtful.  Theology is a hard mistress.
The second experience this week was reading the column by Charles Krauthammer in the Washington Post in which he chastised climate change action advocates on the basis of the inherent uncertainty of science.  This is of course much like the Inquisition’s position in 21st century language.  The science behind climate change has to be a fantasy created by the Devil.  Krauthammer, for example, accused advocates of attributing climate change as the cause of every extreme weather event.  In fact, climatologists and other knowledgeable advocates have been very careful to state that no one event can be attributed to climate change with any certainty.  Instead, they look to the frequency of extreme events as one of many measures of change.  He also criticized over-reliance on computer models, when in fact many of the findings are things like long term (thirty years or more) temperature changes, changes in ranges of species and glacial melting, all observable fact.  And all the findings in the IPCC report are very carefully annotated with degrees of certainty, many of them over 95 percent.  Aside from that, has Charles stepped outside lately?  My brothers on the gulf coast have warned me not to go there between the end of April and the end of September because of the increased heat.  Those moons of Jupiter are really there, Charles.
Theology is a language for talking about sacred things.  When one encounters it, a natural question is, what is the sacred thing?  A charitable explanation is that it is the classical conservative position that the present should not be sacrificed for an uncertain future.  All well and good.  But advocates these days, perhaps too conservatively, are not arguing unreasonable sacrifice; they argue for “no regrets” actions proportional to observed change which will result in good outcomes whatever eventually transpires.  Unfortunately the sacred word that pops to mind in many cases is “Mammon.”  The actions which in many cases are required to ameliorate or adapt to climate change are often community wide, not for the direct personal benefit of any one individual. Personal treasure is threatened, and that is intolerable.

The IPCC report notes that climate change will require cultural and social adaptations as much as it does technical ones.  Perhaps the greatest of those is that we are really going to have to learn how to work together, often altruistically often for the benefit of unborn grandchildren.  In our modern, “follow your own bliss” American culture, that will be very hard for many.  We need to work on this.

Saturday, February 15, 2014

The Chains of Consequences

Corporations have come a long ways from the days when companies such as the British East India Company were creatures of the sovereign, with the mission of spreading empire to faraway places.  Monarchs gave corporations their marching orders, and knew they would be followed.  The East India Company had its own army to speed it along, and succeeded in adding Empress of India to Victoria’s long list of titles.  She had wanted that desperately because her cousin was already an emperor and got to march in first on state occasions.  Actual profits going to anyone were only a secondary concern.
Corporations had started off the same way elsewhere, as arms, sometimes militant, of the nation.  But along the way corporations had begun to be licensed by the monarch indefinitely, with no requirement for renewal. They were immortals!  They soon made their own declarations of independence and dedicated themselves to the pursuit of profits as happiness.  That independence required the evolution of a different kind of social contract; corporations, no longer creatures of the sovereign but not themselves sovereign, still needed the consent of society to function, and that was provided through regulation.  Our policy model for that regulation assumed the mutual interest of the corporation and American society in profit making. Hence the famous declaration that was taken to mean, “What’s good for General Motors is good for America.”  (That’s not what was actually said, but what society in general read into it.)  Howard Meyerson, in the Washington Post this past week, pointed out that the classic American corporate model established was in fact the stakeholder version of capitalism.  In it, profitable business includes value to the shareholders, the employees and to the public.  Companies such as Ford Motor Company are shining   examples of that model.  That model still works in other countries.  A battle royal is currently raging in Tennessee, where Volkswagen seeks to apply it to its new operations there by being friendly to unions in the German style that has made them leaders in adapting to a 21st century high-tech world.  They face stiff opposition in Tennessee, where the Senate president declares such friendliness to be "Un-American." But our social contract with corporations is based on that model, and it is the premise of our corporate regulation policy.  But it was a different kind of profits than we see today.    We have gone astray.
Beginning in the 1970s, an altered ideological stance emerged for corporations.  Libertarian ideologues headed by Milt Friedman argued that the focus of profit making was on shareholder profit as the measure of all things, and that the corporation had no obligation other than to shareholders.  The idea was happily accepted by corporations; it gave them freedom for the kind of global maneuvering we see today.  Now, not only the concerns of the sovereign could be ignored, but the concerns of the people as well.  But acceptance of shareholder capitalism was a major, unrecognized alteration of the social contract.  Corporations no longer needed to include employees in profits, or to spread the benefits of their profits to the communities around them.  Even price gouging and tax evasion become acceptable corporate goals under such ideology.  But the social assumptions underlying corporate regulation had not correspondingly changed.
The consequences have been devastating.  That change in corporate ideology coincides, as Robert Reich has pointed out with the flattening of the wage curve which has resulted in worker earnings remaining flat for the past 35 years while all productivity gains accrued to the top twenty percent, aka the shareholders.  And a consequence of that has been the economic stagnation resulting, again as Reich has pointed out, from lower demand as the public becomes less and less able to afford corporate products.  Regulatory policy that assumes the friendliness, loyalty and community spirit of corporations that have no intent of behaving that way has no chance of success.  We have placed ourselves in economic chains and leg-irons through our own efforts.
We need fundamental restructuring of our corporate regulation policy.   We can no longer assume the corporation as a friendly giant out to help us and our communities along with helping themselves.  No tax breaks should be provided without “poison pills” of very large payments to assure the corporation adheres to its promises and stays around to do so.  Breaks should be provided only with commitments to pay fair wages and benefit the community.  Corporate raids on natural resources like water supplies through things like fracking should be assumed contrary to the public interest unless strongly proved otherwise.  And the burden of proof should be entirely on the corporation.  Corporations have lost the right to public trust, with its consequences for tax breaks and easy regulation. They must work to regain it.


Thursday, February 6, 2014

The Good, The Bad and The Ugly

After three years of negotiations, an agricultural reform bill has finally passed in Congress, and presumably will soon become law.  Some of it involved eliminating outrageous subsidies that go mainly to big corporations.  That’s good.  Stiffer environmental regulations on farms that the bill includes are good, too.  It requires a label showing country of origin on meat.  That’s a good idea in itself, though critics complain it will add costs to the consumer for the sorting of animals at stock yards and may set off trade wars with other countries.  That’s bad.  But the ugly part of the bill is that of the $16 billion in projected savings, over half, $8.6 billion comes from cuts in the food stamp program.  But that was done to avoid a House conservative alternative proposal to cut 5 times as much from the proposal.  The bill is classic compromise legislation, and good, bad or ugly, it’s the face of democracy.
One question that arises is whether in this complicated 21st century, we can any longer afford such compromise.   Fifty years ago in political science, it was popular to talk about “iron triangles.”  The concept was that isolated special interest areas like agriculture are composed of a triangle of interests consisting of a congressional committee (the Agriculture Committees in the House and Senate, a lobbying group (farmers and ranchers) and a bureaucracy (the Agriculture Department).  All decisions are worked out by members of the triangle, and other areas did not intrude.  That’s how subsidies arise and continue like the annual payment to home owners whose house sits on land formerly part of a rice field which encountered hurricane damage.  That was indeed how it worked back then.  But the plight of those in poverty in the cities, environmental issues, international trade agreements, an internet-based world in which everyone knows and is concerned with the business of other, and dozens of other things have turned the triangles into unrecognizable multi-faceted configurations.  Previously, relatively small groups of Congressional leaders cut deals to get things done quickly. Sometimes the results, like the subsidies, were self-interested and against the public interest, but often great things were done.  The Civil Rights Act was passed with the efforts of a relatively small group of Congressional leaders pushed hard by Lyndon Johnson.  Even Johnson couldn’t get it done today.  The face of democracy begins to resemble something done by Picasso, and it’s getting uglier by the year..
Now, the consequences of decisions have widespread impacts no longer ignorable by others.  The particular form food stamp cuts took affects well over a million people in 850,000 households in about a third of the states.  Taking over half the savings out of the incomes of the poor may work as a political compromise, but it ravages the lives of people.  International treaties currently being negotiated will be affected.  Pollution levels are tied in.   Good enough in compromised legislation may no longer be good enough.
Beyond that, many of our problems arise quickly and must be solved quickly.  The long-term unemployment issue is a case in point.  Climate change legislation is another.  Three years topass an inadequate solution no longer suffices.  And beyond that, the results of time-consuming legislation get locked in.  Thirty years ago, Congress in the early days of the Reagan era hastily passed an elimination of the Social Security minimum benefit.  The public outcry caused them just as hastily to repeal what they had done.  When agricultural legislation takes three years to negotiate all the angles, the prospect of changing it is slim.
Congress’s latest success shows just how much Congress is broken.  Some of the causes are obvious.  It’s far too large these days.  435 members in the House generally cannot even agree on an agenda, much less significant legislation.  Its internal procedures are antiquated.  Procedures that made sense in 1814 no longer do.  It’s composed of far too many gerrymandered extremists, etc., etc.  Such a Congress can no longer adequately manage the complexities of today’s society.  None of these problems are at the Constitutional level.  The Constitution does not specify 435 members in the House or 60 votes to invoke cloture in the Senate.  But reform requires willingness of the Congress to address its own structural problems and of states to reduce gerrymandering and it can’t be done entirely from within Congress.  That’s as hard as changing the Constitution.

Congress’s fundamental problem is that it is the victim of culture lag, and that lag includes unwillingness to recognize the problem.  We are relying on a horse-and-buggy congress in a supersonic age, and our Congressional representatives in general don’t even see the problem.  It’s the kind of problem that can only be corrected at the ballot box.  It will require a long, hard push.  It’s time we began.

Friday, January 31, 2014

Ukraine and Leadership

Some ancient (it's been attributed to many) is reputed to have said, “There go my followers.  I must hurry to catch up with them, for I am their leader.”  We laugh at that as a slap at timidity in leadership.  We've always had the idea that the role of leaders is to lead the charge, flag high and sword waving.  But we wouldn't relish our leadership leading a rush of lemmings, including us, over the cliff.  We want bold leadership without bad consequences.  Leadership of lemmings is probably best done from behind.  It was a wiser Machiavelli who said, “Fortune sometimes favors the man who acts boldly, and sometimes favors the man who is cautious, but always favors him who knows when to be bold and when to be cautious.”  That’s the kind of leader we rationally would prefer, but our gut instinct is to cheer on the flag waver.
That’s the dilemma the Obama administration faces these days.  We elected Obama to get us out of foreign entanglements after sobering up from several years of overindulgence in Iraq and Afghanistan.  Yet we chafe at the bit to jump into Syria and Ukraine.  I've noted before that going into Syria is like jumping feet-first into the middle of the 30 Years War, with angry factions shooting at you from all sides no matter what you do and no way of knowing what actually is the right thing to do.  It’s relatively easy from a historical perspective to know that we have to tread cautiously or not at all in the Middle East these days, but we still have that urge to knock heads and fix that mess.  Ukraine is harder.
Viewed one way, the Ukrainian protests remind us of our own American Revolution, with Putin as George III and Kiev as Boston, though Yanukovych is no George Washington or Sam Adams.  It’s hard not to grab your musket and become a Minute Man.  It’s a middle class revolution against foreign tyranny, economic consequences be damned, and from our own history we love it.  Yanukovych is concerned about Ukraine’s indebtedness, and is willing to surrender some of Ukraine’s freedom of action to get rid of it by putting Ukraine back in Russia’s orbit rather than joining the EU.  We, with our history, don’t relish the idea of selling your heritage for a mess of porridge.  But oddly enough, that’s something like what Scotland did in the 1890s when, to rid themselves of debt, the Scots surrendered supremacy of the Scottish parliament to the English parliament in foreign policy.  Scottish separatists are still regretting that more than a century later, but it’s worked in the meantime.  With memories of Edward long shanks, Bonnie Prince Charlie and the fall of the Stuarts, it wasn't easy for the Scots either, but their financial concerns outweighed their history.  There isn't only one right choice.
From another perspective, Ukraine resembles Russia’s Cuba.  With historically grounded paranoid fears of invasion from the south, Russia has always maintained its own Monroe Doctrine by cultivating, coercively or not, a row of allied buffer states.  Ukraine, like Cuba to the U.S., would be a key loss.  We remember how we felt and acted when the Soviet Union began cultivating Cuba and threatened to place missiles there.  It’s an honest concern on Russia’s part, and understandable.  What is less understandable is Yanukovych ignoring the expressed will of his own people.
Once again, Machiavelli reminds us of the value of knowing when to be bold and when to remain cautious.  Ukraine is a matter clearly involving Ukraine itself, the Russians and the EU.  Intruding the U.S. into that volatile mix merely roils the waters without solving anything.
The broader question is when to act boldly in a multi-polar world.  Veering too far toward caution simply leads to isolationism, itself a dangerous course in a constantly changing geopolitical environment.  An obvious set of tests are that resolving the situation is in our national interest, the situation demands action on our part, our action will be decisive and there is a clear exit strategy – somewhat akin to the Powell Doctrine.  In diplomacy, however, those tests are themselves complex and capable of multiple interpretations.  Every hot spot around the world does not require our intervention, and in many a proper course of action is not obvious.  We are no longer caught up in a zero-sum game with the Soviet Union, where each loss for them is a victory for us.  Analysis requires cool heads, and action needs to be unimpeded by domestic overheated rhetoric.  Mobs do not seek for nuances, but sometimes in diplomacy nuanced action is necessary. 
 American politics has never lacked for rhetoric but the level of it has grown much worse since Vietnam gave the press and politicians license to suspect everything.  Younger people may not remember that until Vietnam American presidents avoided domestic criticism by travelling abroad.  The saying was that inside the U.S. the president was head of his party and abroad he represented all of us.  Foreign policy was mostly considered bipartisan territory.   Now senators and celebrities take their own trips abroad to muddle the waters and political criticism does not die down no matter how far the president has travelled.  It sometimes includes even the expression on his face as he meets foreign leaders.  It leaves our friends confused and our enemies chuckling.
The greatest loss is the ability to act cautiously.  Obama showed, to universal acclaim, his ability to act boldly with the raid on the Ben Laden compound.  Every cautious step he takes is heaped with domestic criticism.  But John Wayne is not the model for our diplomacy.  Showing the flag is no longer appropriate to every situation in a multi-polar world.  Obama could do a much better job of explaining the whys of acting cautiously, but he needs political room at home to do so.  The real test of his leadership is his ability to get the American people to understand and go along with his proposed actions.  For that, he needs our ears and minds, not our partisan rhetoric.   We need to provide them.

Wednesday, January 22, 2014

Political Correctness

I’ve experienced lately the distress of “being nibbled to death by mice.”  That’s what an old friend at the office used to call those days when the big things you want to do get overtaken by a multitude of little things that just won’t wait.  One of the things I’d rather have worked on lately has been writing, but there’s been no time.  The mice of January “must do’s” leave no room for excuses, lacking even the empathy of a rat.   I regret that, but it does bring to mind interesting news on the science front.
Recent scientific studies show that rats care about the distress of other rats.  In a study reported in the Washington Post, researchers report that the distress is a product of mammalian socialization, not genetics specific to rats.  That is, all species that raise babies have the capability to respond to distress in others of their species, since babies could not survive if their parent did not respond to their signs of distress.  It is the fundamental building block of empathy, and all mammals possess some degree of it.  Response only to similar members of the same species, such as similarly colored neighbors, is a trained trait learned in childhood.  So, where did Libertarians, with their “cheerful indifference to the needs of others” go wrong?  For, as an example, to a scientist, indifference to the distress of a neighbor much like you who is long-term unemployed is clearly not in accord with natural instinct, but an acquired trait.  It requires refusing to recognize the neighbor as having common human traits.  How, and why, did Libertarians learn to go against natural instinct?  It brings to mind Colbert’s comment that “Reality has a Liberal bias.”  The scientist would probably agree.
The Libertarian might argue that I’m just being “politically correct”, and there’s truth in that.  But what is political correctness in the first place?  Scientific correctness is straight-forward.  A fundamental assumption of science is that there is a “correct” relationship between cause and effect. Smash an atom with an x-ray beam and it will fission, not melt; expose a conditioned dog to the sound of a bell, and it will salivate, not scratch its ear and yawn.  Politics is based on an opposite premise, that there is no “one” correct way to proceed but many, subject to negotiations between parties with differing views and interests.  That in fact is what liberty is all about, the ability to view things in different ways.  We cherish our liberty, and would not want to give it up, even when it requires letting other people be loudly and disastrously wrong-headed.  Libertarians may be going against nature, but they have the right to do so.  That is our true national political correctness, and we remain proud of it.
The problem nowadays is that our views on liberty were developed in a time when all political causes and effects were local, and the world was much less complex.  No one best way was fine in a village argument over locating the school house, but when you’re dealing with the consequences of global climate change or education for a high-tech world economy or the impacts of cross-breeding species of food crops through genetic engineering, it’s a different matter.  There are “best” ways, there are usually severe time-constraints for effective action, ignoring them can be disastrous for billions of people, and finding them requires analysis by experts and willingness to follow uncomfortable courses.  Scientific and political correctness clash head-on.
We've already solved the problem in the financial sector, the one we seem to find the most important. In the U.S. we established the Federal Reserve System, and elsewhere they had already had central banks for many years.  That amounted to delegating to experts the manipulation of the flow of money trough the national economy to avoid debilitating controversy and stalemates arising from the differing interests of all the parties involved.  Climate change and education would seem to be at least as important.  An argument often made against such delegation of major decisions to boards of experts is that it breeds conformity and wide-spread “political correctness”, but it’s hard to spot that as a consequence of the Federal Reserve. Another argument is that expert decisions requiring taxation for funding take your money without your voice, taxation without representation.  But decisions by the Federal Reserve can raise or lower your income dramatically, and we never seem to notice.
The fundamental argument is that each delegation to experts constitutes a lessening of individual liberty.  That’s a substantive argument, and the consequences of ignoring it can be seen in totalitarian regimes like the former USSR or Communist China, where boards of experts planned everything from factory quotas to the number of children you could have.  A creeping conformity can in fact overwhelm whole nations in disastrous ways.  But your liberty ends at the tip of another person's nose, and here we're counting billions of noses.  And there are correct ways to proceed. As it stands, we are simply using individual experts as weapons to cudgel opponents rather than collecting and using effectively the consensus of the entire scientific community.  A delegation to  a board of experts by Congress in specific areas like climate change or genetic engineering, with their conclusions accepted or rejected In Toto, would seem to address that concern.  

We live in a complex and dangerous world where major choices must be made and implemented correctly and quickly.  It is disastrously outdated to think those choices can be made as in olden times, around the village elm with the decision going to those who can talk loudest and longest.  The world will not wait for our decisions.

Saturday, January 11, 2014

Insurmountable Opportunities

Back in my office days, we used to look at crises as they arose – there was always at least the “Friday afternoon flap” and often things much worse – and call them “insurmountable opportunities.”  It’s based on the old saying, which may or may not be accurate, that the Chinese character for crisis is a combination of the characters for danger and opportunity.  That’s somewhat akin to Rahm Emmanuel’s famous comment that no crisis should be wasted.
There’s nothing particularly new in the UN report on climate change, due to come out on Monday and whose executive summary was released Friday, except two things.  A number of drafts have been floating around for a while, and it reports the same dismal things as heard previously, only, in some cases, as in sea level rises, sounding worse.  The first new thing was a level of certainty of 95 percent for climate change being caused by human activity.  That’s polite scientific language for “really sure.”  It’s the level of certainty about your condition a surgeon would like, but sometimes doesn't have, before cutting you open.  It’s far beyond the “preponderance of evidence” a civil jury would need to find you guilty of contributory negligence; fossil fuel corporations should remember that.  In other words, we have ourselves to blame.  It’s hard to understand why people who would accept surgery on less evidence still refuse to accept man-made climate change.  They’re valuing their wallet over their internal organs.  That would be a really good study for the social psychologists.
The second new thing was the certainty that climate change will continue for centuries with temperatures rising above 2 degrees Celsius despite what we do.  That means prevention is definitely too late and amelioration and adaptation are now definitely the goals.  That, strangely enough, could be a big part of the solution to our economic problems.  Countering and making use of the effects of climate change could be, and eventually will be, a major new economic sector. Industries and jobs will be created, if not here than certainly elsewhere.  We should make sure they’re here.   I've mentioned the major infrastructure issues to be dealt with many times.  Rising seas and more severe storms mean major new construction.  Green technology is very slowly, and with lots of resistance, coming on board.  That change is occurring much too slowly; a noted historian of energy technology predicted recently that natural gas will be the dominant fuel for the next 50 to 60 years, with wind and solar only becoming dominant after that.  We need lots bigger pushes in those technology areas.  But things are beginning also to get interesting in the adaptation area.
Adaptation is already thriving in other countries.  Remember how rising temperatures are sure to produce more droughts with the need for desalinization of sea water, and of course, much less snow.  An Israeli company is making good money converting sludge from desalinization into artificial snow for resorts.  Other adaptation startups are popping up all over.  There should be a boom in the pipeline industry.  New materials are needed for insulation.  As climate changes some areas will fade and others boom.  Innovative building construction and land development should really grow.   Urban agriculture is a wave of the future. They've used green houses in Crete for many years to grow vegetables protected against the sun.   What is lacking here is not opportunity, but the imagination to use the many opportunities that exist. 

A problem we have to deal with these days is all the entrenched technology, which owners want to hang on to rather than facing the risk of exploiting the new.  When Marconi invented the telegraph, he first tried selling it to France, but it was rejected there because of the competing existing businesses.  He took it to America, where it became an instant success because there was nothing to compete with it.  We increasingly act like France did rather than America, to our loss.  What we need are policies which encourage, possibly though temporary subsidies and tax breaks, the innovations needed to ameliorate and adapt to climate change.  The innovators should not be in it alone.  We all have an interest in their success.  Climate change is a crisis that should not be wasted.

Monday, January 6, 2014

Irrational Ignorance

It’s strange the little things you can learn sometimes from abroad about your own country’s history.  A Dutch reporter recently cited an exchange between Henry Ford and Walter Reuther, the head of the auto workers’ union. Ford was showing Reuther a newly automated factory and said to him, ”Walter, how are you going to get those robots to pay union dues?”  To which Reuther replied, “Henry, how are you going to get them to buy cars?”  Sometimes it’s more complicated than that.  Boeing has been negotiating with its machinists’ union, trying to get them to agree to 401(k)’s instead of fixed benefit pensions, along with other concessions.  The workers don’t buy planes, though if they can any longer afford it, they are passengers.  Boeing is using the usual corporate ploy of threatening to move its new plane operations elsewhere, to “ensure it remains competitive” and of course to guarantee its CEO his over $100 million annual compensation package.  Latest word is that the machinists have caved in and agreed.  It’s just another lost battle in the erosion of worker and retiree income that comes about from the capability of corporations to move elsewhere.  It's what economists like Robert Reich, Larry Summers and Joseph Stiglitz regard as a basis for the continued stagnation in our economy.  But it may echo in Congress and elsewhere also.

2014 is the year issues meet head-to-head during negotiation over proposed trade pacts between the U.S. and both the EU and China.  Negotiations have been going on in secret with mainly corporate interests in the loop, but the Obama administration is promising to protect worker interests.   But agreement by the workers and the Congress is going to take a lot of trust, and Boeing is not helping any.  At the same time as it’s negotiating secret trade pacts to promote American exports, the administration is promising to reduce income inequality and protect worker rights.  The goals seem at cross purposes, since profitable exports are generally perceived as requiring low labor costs at home.  At the same time, Larry Summers points out that the real roadblock to a robust economy is inadequate demand for goods and services, and low-paid workers are not going to do much in the way of stimulating demand.  He seems to be echoing Reuther, while the corporate interests are talking like Ford.  We're facing the kinds of policy choices that would benefit greatly from the input of a well-informed public, but that's not what seems to be happening.  Left strictly to the markets and to secret corporation negotiators, the workers are most likely to lose again.  It seems the only way really to cure income inequality and the economy is not from within the usual market mechanisms, which give power only to the corporations, but with the electorate.  The fact that trade negotiations are occurring during an election year may prove interesting.

George Will of course would prefer that those ignorant voters not get in the way of clever negotiators.  In a recent column, he opines that the principal problem with democracy is… democracy!  He quotes favorably Churchill’s quip that “the strongest argument against democracy is a five-minute conversation with the average voter.”  He bases his views on the “public choices” view of economic theory which holds that “rational ignorance” prevents voters from being well informed on policy choices, and makes them opt for “sentimental” (that seems his code word for considering the needs of others) solutions, rather than the market-based solutions he prefers. He seems to think we would all be better off just letting the markets decide things.  George forgets – surely his education must have included it – that in a democracy, the voting process is a principal means of legitimizing government and stabilizing society.

Rational ignorance is the failure to learn about a topic resulting from a decision that knowing about it won’t affect your life much.  But policy decisions do affect your life a lot.  It’s just that in a market economy where the corporate interests hold the reins of power, only political means are available to the “average voter” to affect outcomes.  The voting booth becomes the “market” in which he can express his choices in a meaningful way.  George could have more closely examined the “average voter” and found that the principal difference between him or her and the corporate negotiator is not in rational ignorance – the negotiators have plenty of that themselves - they understand how policy options affect markets, but not people.  The real difference lies in the quality of their education and the extent of their self interest.  The negotiator, like George, is much better educated and much more happily uninterested in the fortunes of others.  But part of the cure for the ignorance of both the average voter and the negotiator is supposed to be democracy itself.  George could have quoted Churchill saying that “the only thing worse than democracy as a form of government is all other forms of government.”  Or Lincoln saying “God must love the common man because he made so many of him.”  Or Alexander Pope acidly remarking that “How God feels about riches can be seen from those he bestows them on.”   Take that, Donald Trump! 

A quality education in a democracy is supposed to be a public good available to all, provided through public funding as a benefit for all.  It was Jefferson who emphasized that with his sponsoring of the University of Virginia, in his own words, his greatest achievement. If the average voter is not even aware enough to know at least roughly the impacts of policy on his life, then we have failed to achieve a necessary goal of democracy.  The price of liberty is both eternal vigilance and quality education.  If agricultural policy is going to raise or lower the cost of a loaf of bread by a dollar for the average voter, or put or take out a million dollars from the pocket of a billionaire, there is no reason the average voter should rationally be less interested than the billionaire.  Yet elite educations even at the high school level generally include some economics and political science and other subjects needed to better understand policy choices, while much public education is deficient in all that. The deficiency continues at college levels.  The “average voter” starts off with a major educational handicap.  It is that handicap which must be cured for effective democracy, and that requires the enlightened funding which many of the prosperous are so unwilling to provide.


Back in the days of slavery, slaves were prohibited from learning to read and write; their owners knew that an educated person would not willingly remain a slave.  Now in the 21st century, education must go far beyond the rudiments if we are to maintain ourselves as a free and prosperous nation.  That requires loosened pockets among those who have already benefited from their own superior education.   To overweight ignorance as a factor in policy choices is to turn it simply into an excuse for ignoring the genuine needs of the economically powerless. That  itself displays a kind of irrational ignorance, for it leads not only to the kind of economic stagnation we have been experiencing, but to economic and political strife.